Tony's Meat Market of Montauk

The staff were very friendly. We can find lost items that we want there. The selections were good. They open from 5 am to 9 pm within minutes from the beach, so it’s very convenient.

Tony’s Meat market has a variety of ready- made food, meats, desserts, coffee, veggies, canned goods and pastas. While I work on a project in montauk, there were not many places open for lunch. Our staff come here to pick up sandwiches and salad. We tried “ the Hither Hills” sandwich and took it to Gorman’s dock to have a lunch. It was big enough to share and delicious. Some items were more on the expensive side, but compare to other places in Montauk, I think price was reasonable. When I come to Montauk for the summer, I will definitely come to Tony’s to pick up some salad and sandwiches.

Located in the Gosman’s Marina area, Tony’s is an addiction! You are greeted by the well stocked deli and pulled into the market by the delicious smells of homestyle cooking. Everything you might need is there - dairy, dry goods, even your favorite breakfast cereals. Don’t want to cook? Go to Tony’s. You’ll be happy you did.

Went here June 20th 2025 for lunch. I got a burger that was completely wrong due to people not being able to understand. Sent it back TWICE for them to send it out the same. Spent 20 plus minutes in there and an absurd amount of money. Was definitely not worth it. Do not waste your money, go somewhere else!!

i ve been a regular to montauk since 2019 and am happy to have tonys here. not only meat but other basic grocery as well

This place is AWESOME! I am new around here as I’m opening up a restaurant a little down the road. I walked in with my service dog, Piper the Golden Retriever and I was very warmly greeted by Gill the manager and Monica, who was working at the register. I ordered a hot pastrami Reuben sandwich and I also got a bag of deep river chips and a soda. I’m eating the sandwich now and it is sooooo dang good I put it down to write this review but I’m going to keep this quick so I can get back to this delicious and enormous sandwich. The pastrami is fabulous. The break tastes like it was made fresh this morning. I didn’t mind the $24 it all cost because it was very well worth it. There is a huge selection of prepared food and a small grocery/sundries section. Tony’s is going to be my go-to spot this summer.

Good for bucher and deli products and misc gormet stuff. Fresh and good quality.

Half gallon of Planet Oat Oatmilk $8.29. What? $5 at a up Island store. $11 for scramble egg and tomato on a onion roll. NFW! Started off as a nice local deli/meat market. Now just another price gouging store. Will not step foot in there again. Owners should be ashamed of themselves.

Chips, cookies, a personal soda and bottle of water $26, enough said? Place was empty though, no lines smh

Open late on a Sunday! Score!! Lots of quality options for dry goods and condiments. Big butcher selection. Can't go wrong here. I recommend

Great market for take out and shopping for meals.

The Onion Steak Sandwich was horrible, the bread is good, the bacon egg and cheese. is good, bacon was greasy. 25$ for one of the worst sandwiches ever. Soggy, horrible sauce, good portions.

Fully stocked market on that end of town-we need it. Fresh meats as well as baked goods and household supplies. The coffee to go is excellent, the store is immaculate and the people are nice. The meat case looked real nice, I would definitely shop here over anything else in Montauk.

It's so sad what the prices have gotten to in this place and all the places in Montauk to be honest. $8 for a small pack of basil, $5 plain bagel, etc. It is just robbery. A shame because it is a nice spot.

Very good sandwiches. A little confusing at first.

Tony's has become my new go-to spot when spending time at my home in Montauk. I love that I don't have to pack coolers of meat and groceries from my house up island anymore. Best addition to MTK in a long time!

Great sandwich’s and prepared food. Butcher counter is extensive and expensive but really good. Definitely a gourmet style market. Perfect for sandwich for the beach or steaks at home for dinner.

Love love love!! Tony’s has been for my high highs and low lows. Egg sandwiches are bomb. Amazing customer service!

A wonder selection and obvious attention to detail.

Most expensive Deli I’ve ever encountered, but you pay for what you get in this world. They have top quality everything and they are open year round. Great place